KDA Today

KDA Today

For Immediate Release

Date: Aug 4th, 2011
Contact: Dr. John Thompson
Phone: 800-292-1855
Email: info@kyda.org

OMG, what is EBD?

Here we go again. The ADA has another set of acronyms that are supposedly meaningful to a practicing dentist.  For some reason the ADA keeps sending me surveys to take online.  I think I have been identified as obsessive-compulsive (OCD) and they know I will most likely respond to the survey if it is not too long. Yesterday I received an e-mail requesting that I complete an online survey on “evidence based dentistry (EBD)”.  Well I’ve been practicing dentistry for forty years and one of my favorite lines that I drop on my staff when we change procedures or materials is “studies show”, therefore; I know all about evidence based dentistry.

If you can “flunk” a survey, I did!  What is a meta-analysis?  What is the 2011 EBD Champions Conference? Have you visited the online ADA Center for Evidence-based Dentistry?  Why should I?

Today my JADA arrived with a cover story “Exploring the Effectiveness of Articaine and Lidocaine as Pulpal Anesthetics”.  I immediately know I am going to read this “studies show” article.  The editorial by Dr. Michael Glick, “Justifying Changes in Clinical Practice”, was the first thing I read and the dots began to connect.  Dr. Glick wrote, “A baffling but interesting trend has emerged in medicine and other scientific fields whereby outcomes from studies performed years ago no longer can be replicated. This phenomenon has called into question, not only the validity of available evidence, but also the prevailing scientific method, which is grounded on the reproducibility of study results. Some of the most revered doctrines in dentistry—G. V. Black’s principle of extension for prevention, for example—have been supplanted by the introduction of new materials, techniques and novel methodologies for evaluating clinical outcomes.”  If you can no longer trust the principles of Dr. Black, who can you trust?

Dr. Glick goes on to say, “Unquestionably, clinical practice should be supported with the best available evidence... There are several sources professionals can draw upon for evidence-based information regarding oral health care, including the ADA’s own web-site on evidence-based-dentistry (http://ebd.ada.org/)...” I think he just answered yesterday’s question of “why should I?”  While reading the cover story, “The Pulpal Anesthetic Efficacy of Articaine Versus Lidocaine in Dentistry”, I see that the sub title is “a Meta-analysis”. I did not know what it was yesterday and now I am going to find out by Googling the term in Wikipedia:

“In statistics, a meta-analysis combines the results of several studies that address a set of related research hypotheses. In its simplest form, this is normally by identification of a common measure of effect size, for which a weighted average might be the output of a meta-analyses. Here the weighting might be related to sample sizes within the individual studies. More generally there are other differences between the studies that need to be allowed for, a smaller "effect size" derived in a single study under a given single set of assumptions and conditions.”

Now I think I know what I am about to read and how to value the final paragraph on implications for practice. The bottom line was that I had just read an unbiased review of validated studies from multiple resources that provided a logical conclusion that would affect the purchase of local anesthetics for our practice.

The dental literature is rife with advertizing that allows manufacturers to make certain claims based on limited or flawed studies. I began to look through a number of throw away publications that come across my desk on a daily basis and observed that the claims for one step bonding systems were very attractive. The question was “How accurate are the claims being made?” I decided to test the ADA’s EBD website for an answer.

For me, the test of bond strength to dentin is the class five composite restorations in the esthetic zone. Therefore I went to ebd.ada.org and under systemic reviews/restorative dentistry/materials, the first reference I found was “Clinical Performance of Cervical Restorations – a meta – analysis” from Dental Materials 2010:26. The abstract was easy to read and cut straight to the chase with a closing that provided this very pertinent information:

“SIGNIFICANCE: The clinical performance of cervical restorations is significantly influenced by the type of adhesive system used and/or the adhesive class to which the system belonged and whether the dentin/enamel is prepared or not. 2-Step self-etching- and 3-step etch&rinse systems shall be chosen over 1-step self-etching systems and glass ionomer derivates. The dentin (and enamel) surface shall be roughened before placement of the restoration.”

Since I agree with this statement I am very impressed with this resource from the ADA that provides relevant clinical research data in a usable and easy to access format. What if I did not agree with the conclusion of the ADA’s EBD research? When I consider what I just read, I see “shall” used two times in this three sentence paragraph.  Having chaired the committee that was charged with writing “Parameters of Care for Dentistry” when Kentucky decided to have health care reform in the mid ‘90s, I vividly recall the discussions that took place regarding “should” and “shall”. Should is a recommendation and shall is a dictum.

The continuum of care that we provide our patients will not always be consistent with “best practices” or “evidence based dentistry” and we have to use our diagnostic skills and sound clinical judgment when circumstances force us to deviate in the treatment we provide. The weight of the American Dental Association should not be armament for a plaintiff’s attorney when sound care, skill and judgment do not result in the intended outcome. Based on what I now know about EBD, I am completely in favor of the information this service will provide the practicing dentist as a counter to the plethora of claims made on the conclusions drawn from biased research.

It is my hope that we shall soon see Evidence Based Dentistry as an indispensible service provided by our most prestigious professional organization and not as another layer of governance. I always feel better when I find something new and beneficial, and I think I have. I hope you are having a good day and bring on the next ADA survey.                             John A. Thompson, DMD   06/23/2011

Press Releases

Click on any title below to read the press release. The release will open up in a new browser window with no menus or images, so that you may print or copy the press release without extraneous graphics.

Feb 20th, 2014UofL Brightening the Smiles of Children
Feb 20th, 2014UKCD’s First Regional Dental Program: The First Ten Years
Feb 20th, 2014Medicaid: An Example of Missing the Goals for Oral Health in Kentucky
Feb 20th, 2014Where Do We Go From Here?
Feb 20th, 2014Go Tell It on the Mountains
Dec 23rd, 2013Welcome Dental Students and New Dentists!
Dec 23rd, 2013Letting the Secret Out
Dec 23rd, 2013It Is What They Left Behind
Dec 23rd, 2013Dr. John Thompson Awarded Distinguished Editor Award
Dec 23rd, 2013Teamwork Creates Champions: the Kentucky Meeting: March 13-16, 2014
Dec 23rd, 2013Listen to Interviews with our Speakers!
Dec 23rd, 20132014 Kentucky Meeting Details
Oct 17th, 2013I Still Like Maps!
Oct 17th, 2013Ground Game
Oct 17th, 2013Kentucky Department of Insurance, HB 497 and Non-covered Services
Oct 17th, 2013Dr. Janet Faraci Lee’s Legacy
Oct 17th, 2013Dr. Janet Faraci Lee Leadership Development Award
Aug 12th, 2013The Affordable Care Act: What does it mean for Our Members?
Aug 12th, 2013Delinquent Accounts….Collections…..YUCK!
Aug 12th, 2013White Crosses
Aug 12th, 2013KDA Membership…Where Do We Go from Here?
Aug 12th, 2013Thoughts from a New Dentist: the Top Three Reasons that I am Involved with Organized Dentistry
Aug 12th, 2013How can KDAIS Benefit You, as a KDA member?
Aug 12th, 2013Beyond the Website: Marketing on the Modern Web
Aug 12th, 2013Every Patient Matters. So Does Every Transaction.
Aug 12th, 2013All Membership Is Local
Jun 13th, 2013The Foundation of the Kentucky Dental Association: Positioned to Make a Powerful Statement
Jun 13th, 2013Something I Wish I Didn't Know!
Jun 13th, 2013Preaching to the Choir
Apr 15th, 2013Participate in Your KDPAC! Contribute and Deliver
Apr 15th, 2013The Pediatric Dental Benefit: Must Offer, May Purchase…
Apr 15th, 2013Exchange What?
Apr 15th, 2013So Long, Farewell, Auf Wiedersehen, Adieu
Apr 15th, 2013United We Stand, Divided We Fall
Feb 12th, 2013It’s a Dentist Thing
Feb 12th, 2013A Profession in Flux
Feb 12th, 2013Living Is What You Do When Life Gets In the Way
Feb 12th, 2013The Tip of the Iceberg: Actions by the Kentucky Department for Medicaid Services Which May Sink KMAP
Oct 19th, 2012Self-Regulation
Oct 19th, 2012House Bill 1 and What It Means to You
Oct 19th, 2012Membership Matters
Aug 21st, 2012The Perception of Dentistry
Aug 21st, 2012Sarrell Dental: Beyond the Operatory
Jun 18th, 2012I Had an Uncle…
Jun 18th, 2012What Part of the “Affordable Care Act” Has Been Affordable?
Jun 18th, 2012Leadership or Politics?
Apr 6th, 2012The "New Old" Still have Teeth
Apr 6th, 2012What a Year, so far!
Apr 6th, 2012Many Thanks for a Great and Memorable Year
Feb 21st, 2012All for One and One for All!
Feb 21st, 2012Happy New Normal
Dec 19th, 2011The Wide World of Sports
Dec 19th, 2011Access to Care?
Oct 28th, 2011To the KDA Executive Board and the entire KDA
Oct 28th, 2011Report of the Sixth District Trustee
Oct 18th, 2011Word-of-Mouth on Steroids!
Oct 18th, 2011Managed Care and Dentistry in Kentucky: a Dentist’s Dilemma
Oct 18th, 2011Why We Shouldn't Lose Sight of Our Purpose...
Aug 4th, 2011CAPWIZ: Legislative Advocacy Made Easy
Aug 4th, 2011OMG, what is EBD?
Aug 4th, 2011Mentor a Young Dentist and Change a Life
Jun 13th, 2011I Might Soon Be Coming to a Town Near You...
Jun 13th, 2011Outside Our Line
Apr 18th, 2011On Your Side, Not Your List
Apr 18th, 2011Blindsided
Apr 18th, 2011I Pledge to Be your Humble Servant…
Apr 18th, 2011Let Me Ask For a Minute of Your Time
Feb 17th, 2011Dr. Andy Elliott for President-elect of the American Dental Association
Feb 4th, 2011Adjusting Attitudes
Feb 4th, 2011A Little Planning Really Helps
Jan 4th, 2011Dental Management of Patients Taking Antiplatelet Medications
Nov 30th, 2010Delegates Report from the 2010 American Dental Association House of Delegates, Orlando, Florida
Nov 30th, 2010Holiday Greetings to All
Nov 30th, 2010Dental Education Found Worthy
Oct 25th, 2010Delegates Report from the 2010 American Dental Association House of Delegates, Orlando, Florida
Oct 7th, 2010We Need To Do a Better Job of Communicating
Oct 7th, 2010Who Will Speak for Me?
Oct 7th, 2010I’m in a Hurry!
Oct 7th, 2010What If …?
Oct 7th, 2010What Happens in Alaska, doesn’t Stay in Alaska
Aug 6th, 2010Kentucky's Dental Practice Act: The Passing of an Old Friend
Aug 6th, 2010The Times They Are Changing
Jun 10th, 2010How a Star was Born
Jun 10th, 2010I Need Your Help…
Apr 20th, 2010President's Message MA 2010
Apr 20th, 2010KDA and Louisville Water Company Share 150th Birthday and Public Health Vision
Apr 20th, 2010Getting It Right!
Feb 25th, 2010What is a Legacy?
Feb 25th, 2010Please Join Us for an Exciting, Event-Filled Year Ahead!
Dec 14th, 2009Challenging the Myth of the Suicide-Prone Dentist
Dec 14th, 2009There is Hope: Suicide Awareness and Prevention in Kentucky
Dec 14th, 2009Holiday Reflections…
Nov 6th, 2009Break your Right Arm and Suddenly You have Time to Study Economics.
Nov 6th, 2009Don’t Balance Health Care Books by Shortchanging Physicians
Jun 26th, 2009Making the World a Better Place, One Village at a Time!
Apr 13th, 2009Breaking Glass
Feb 20th, 2009At the Heart of any Worthy Project is a Committed Volunteer